1300 East 9th Street, Suite 1950 ● Cleveland, Ohio  44114-1501

Phone (216) 875-2767 ● Fax (216) 875-1570

Trials & Arbitration

 

Bonezzi Switzer Murphy Polito & Hupp Co. L.P.A. is a law firm engaged in medical malpractice defense, hospital and nursing home defense, toxic tort/asbestos defense litigation, employment law, worker's compensation defense, family law, property and casualty defense, general liability defense, appellate and probate.

 

When an attorney from BSMPH is in trial they are not alone.  The resources of the entire firm are at their disposal.  They can call upon any of the attorneys or paralegals in the office and receive all the assistance that may be required in a given case.
The FirmPractice AreasTrials & ArbitrationFirm DirectoryLocationEmploymentContact Us
 

 

The results of trials and arbitrations are shown right. Please contact us at 216-875-2767 if we can be of service to you.

 

| 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 |

| 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 1999 | 1998 |

 

 

 

 

 

 

2008
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Sebaugh/Stephenson Merrill Cuyahoga CV-07-619737 Defense Verdict
2. Ensign Dahlen Cuyahoga CV-05-565915 Direct Verdict (for Defendant)
3. Hupp/Stephenson Rees Cuyahoga CV-06-597504 Plaintiff's Verdict*
4. Reinker Feinstein Cuyahoga CV-06-583923 Defense Verdict
5. Murphy Rivera Cuyahoga CV-06-607205 Plaintiff's Verdict*
6. Bonezzi/Kadlec Fischer Cuyahoga CV-07-615514 Plaintiff's Verdict
7. Switzer Abels Summit CV-03-020787 Defense Verdict
8. Bonezzi/Stephenson Hoff Cuyahoga CV-08-645773 Defense Verdict
9. Hupp Hughes Lorain 03-CV-136738 Defense Verdict
10. Switzer Ross Cuyahoga CV-06-605099 Settled During Trial
11. Sebaugh/Stephenson Todd Lucas CIO-2006-04977 Defense Verdict
12. Bonezzi/Perry Houser Mahoning 04-CV-02134 Defense Verdict
13. Switzer Wahl Lake CV-07-002722 Defense Verdict
14. Sebaugh Jones Lorain 07-CA-009171 Defense Verdict
15. Bonezzi/Stephenson Monroe Trumbull 2007CV02107 Defense Verdict
16. Hupp/Perry Thompson Cuyahoga CV-07-622712 Plaintiff's Verdict
         
* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

2007
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Sebaugh Amirault Cuyahoga CV-05-574702 Defense Verdict
2. Switzer Lambert Ashtabula 2005-CV-00283 Defense Verdict
3. Sebaugh/Holdsworth Naboka Cuyahoga CV-05-566619 Defense Verdict
4. Reinker/Holdsworth Ramirez Cuyahoga CV-05-578528 Defense Verdict
5. Bonezzi/Perry Eastman Cuyahoga CV-05-559595 Defense Verdict
6. Hupp Davis Lake CV-05-001324 Defense Verdict
7. Polito Freeman Cuyahoga CV-06-593391 Defense Verdict
8. Murphy Griffith Wood 2005-CV-705 Defense Verdict
9. Bonezzi Martin Cuyahoga CV-06-602138 Defense Verdict
10. Hupp Berlin Cuyahoga CV-02-479340 Defense Verdict
11. Bonezzi Nalepa Cuyahoga CV-05-557051 Defense Verdict
         
* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2006
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Bonezzi/Miller Cahill Cuyahoga CV-04-539814 Defense Verdict
2. Bonezzi/Miller Lucarell Mahoning 03-CV-2976 Defense Verdict
3. Murphy/Thomas Rios Cuyahoga CV-05-558601 Defense Verdict
4. Polito/Perry Freeman Cuyahoga CV-05-552401 Defense Verdict
5. Hupp/Quallich Nordquist Mahoning 02-CV-2395 Settled During Trial*
6. Switzer Vakilian Franklin 2004-CV-0960 Defense Verdict
7. Murphy Och Cuyahoga CV-04-534439 Plaintiff's Verdict (no payment required due to prior set off)
8. Reinker/Perry DiSalle Lucas CIO-2002-01568 Defense Verdict
9. Hupp/Perry Orne Cuyahoga CV-05-559877 Defense Verdict
10. Sebaugh/Quallich Grady Cuyahoga CV-04-518450 Defense Verdict
11. Bonezzi/Miller Cooper Erie 2003-CV-066 Settled During Trial*
12. Switzer Black Cuyahoga CV-06-583865 Defense Verdict
13. Sebaugh Black Cuyahoga CV-06-583865 Defense Verdict
14. Bonezzi/Miller Weimer Stark 2006-CV-01008 Settled During Trial*
         
* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2005
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Polito/Perry Randall Cuyahoga CV-02-466171 Settled During Trial
2. Polito Yeagley Cuyahoga CV-01-452611 Settled During Trial
3. Sweeney Saunders Cuyahoga CV-04-534858 Plaintiff's Verdict
4. Polito/Sebaugh Partyka Lorain 02-CV-131629 Defense Verdict
5. Murphy/Thomas Clark Cuyahoga CV-03-498845 Defense Verdict
6. Bonezzi/Miller Workman Lake CV-03-000689 Defense Verdict
7. Sebaugh Leiblinger Cuyahoga CV-03-517765 Defense Verdict
8. Murphy/Thomas Kozelka Cuyahoga CV-04-537444 Defense Verdict
9. Murphy/Thomas Atassi Cuyahoga CV-04-522769 Defense Verdict
10. Sebaugh/Quallich Sirianni Cuyahoga CV-03-498019 Defense Verdict
11. Reinker Rillahan Lake CV-04-000436 Defense Verdict
12. Sebaugh/Quallich Zampino Cuyahoga CV-03-509138 Settled During Trial
13. Perry Arnette Summit CV-2003-08-4604 Defense Verdict
14. Hupp/Perry Grubaugh Cuyahoga CV-04-526797 Defense Verdict
15. Quallich Mahmet Cuyahoga CV-05-55593 Defense Verdict
16. Perry/Hupp Evans Lucas CIO-2003-03744 Plaintiff's Verdict*
17. Murphy Barnes Cuyahoga CV-2004-548117 Plaintiff's Verdict*
18. Reinker Wasmire Stark 2003-CV-02830 Defense Verdict
19. Hupp/Perry Johnson Cuyahoga CV-04-524947 Defense Verdict
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2004
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Reinker Appel Cuyahoga CV-02-472459 Defense Verdict
2. Hupp/Perry Brunnett Cuyahoga CV-02-477603 Defense Verdict
3. Hupp/Miller Savage Cuyahoga CV-02-469777 Defense Verdict
4. Murphy/Holdsworth Layne Stark CV-03-0962 Defense Verdict
5. Hupp Mihlan Mahoning 01-CV-444 Plaintiff's Verdict *
6. Switzer Zeidner Cuyahoga 01-CV-457124 Settled During Trial
7. Polito/Hupp Cooper Cuyahoga 02-CV-474323 Defense Verdict
8. Bonezzi Gerakis Cuyahoga 02-CV-484862 Settled During Trial
9. Hupp/Perry Berlin Cuyahoga 02-CV-479340 Directed Verdict
10. Polito/Perry Bissonnette Cuyahoga 01-CV-456671 Defense Verdict
11. Murphy/Thomas Braggs Cuyahoga 03-CV-518038 Defense Verdict
12. Bonezzi Morgan Mahoning 97-CV-00277 Arbitration Award for Plaintiff
13. Bonezzi Huff Franklin 03-CVA-0505794 Settled During Trial
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2003
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Reinker Gibbons Cuyahoga CV-01-431750 Defense Verdict
2. Hupp Traska Cuyahoga CV-00-405892 Settled During Trial
3. Switzer Rizk Cuyahoga CV-01-451962 Plaintiff's Verdict
4. Bonezzi Sawyer Cuyahoga CV-01-444417 Plaintiff's Verdict
5. Murphy Perla Cuyahoga CV-01-456963 Defense Verdict
6. Sebaugh Hicks U.S.D.C. 01-CV-7153 Defense Verdict
7. Hupp Mason Cuyahoga 01-CV-457870 Defense Verdict
8. Sweeney Scheel-Englehart Cuyahoga CV-01-428384 Plaintiff's Verdict *
9. Murphy Danzinger Cuyahoga CV-00-426717 Defense Verdict
10. Murphy Hausman Summit CV-2002-01-0590 Settled During Trial (without payment by our insured)
11. Murphy Gonzales Lorain 01-CV-128214 Defense Verdict
12. Sebaugh/Sweeney Price Cuyahoga CV-02-474960 Defense Verdict
13. Murphy Takacs Cuyahoga CV-00-414360 Defense Verdict
14. Buckner Budner Summit CV-2002-02-1047 Settled During Jury Deliberations
15. Buckner Panella Summit CV-2002-05-2783 Defense Verdict
16. Bonezzi Strouth Franklin 00-CVA-064935 Settled During Trial
17. Murphy Lenhart Wood 2002-CV-028 Defense Verdict
18. Reinker Brogan Lucas CIO-001-03642 Plaintiff's Verdict
19. Heffernan Ozakaynak Berea Municipal 03-CV-101048 Defense Verdict
20. Buckner Niederst Cuyahoga CV-01-441889 Defense Verdict
21. Hupp Peat Cuyahoga CV-02-482825 Defense Verdict
22. Switzer Robinson Portage 2001-CV-00146 Defense Verdict
23. Bonezzi Bach Cuyahoga CV-02-470041 Plaintiff's Verdict
24. Buckner Del Monico Summit CV-2002-10-5918 Directed Verdict
25. Polito/Perry Lapore Cuyahoga CV-02-467610 Defense Verdict
26. Bonezzi Beavers Cuyahoga CV-00-412065 Settled During Trial
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2002
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Hupp Cetlinski U.S.D.C. 3:00CV-7073 Defense Verdict
2. Polito Turner Cuyahoga CV-00-400797 Directed Verdict
3. Murphy Gilbert Cuyahoga CV-01-428169 Plaintiff's Verdict *
4. Dapore Parker Cuyahoga CV-00-423721 Defense Verdict
5. Hupp Blogna Cuyahoga CV-00-424926 Defense Verdict
6. Dapore Johnson Lucas CIO-000-02294 Defense Verdict
7. Hupp Wise Wayne 00-CV-0261 Defense Verdict
8. Bonezzi McDonald Lucas CIO-00-02050 Defense Verdict
9. Murphy Appleton Lorain 00-CV-125528 Directed Verdict
10. Sweeney Violand Cuyahoga CV-00-429742 Plaintiff's Verdict
11. Murphy Schaeffer Lorain 99-CV-123719 Defense Verdict
12. Bonezzi Zedan Cuyahoga CV-99-374294 Plaintiff's Verdict
13. Murphy Minnick Lucas CIO-00-02451 Defense Verdict
14. Murphy Deery Cuyahoga CV-01-445149 Defense Verdict
15. Polito Kishman Cuyahoga 00-CV-126485 Defense Verdict
16. Switzer Daugherty Richland 01-345D Defense Verdict
17. Polito Chang Cuyahoga CV-00-403722 Dismissed During Trial
18. Kiss Steinmetz Erie 98-CV-462 Defense Verdict
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2001
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Bonezzi Davis Cuyahoga CV-99-391167 Defense Verdict
2. Bonezzi Busson Medina 99-CV-1037 Defense Verdict
3. Bonezzi Flickinger Summit CV-1999-10-4309 Defense Verdict
4. Murphy Reynolds Lorain 98-CV-122012 Plaintiff's Verdict
5. Murphy Thomas Lorain 99-CV-123053 Defense Verdict
6. Hupp Macholl Summit CV-1999-08-3047 Plaintiff's Verdict
7. Hupp Khenkin Cuyahoga CV-99-392509 Plaintiff's Verdict *
8. Hupp Steele Cuyahoga CV-00-421892 Defense Verdict
9. Hupp Bevis Cuyahoga CV-00-413976 Defense Verdict
10. Polito Tomadjoglou Cuyahoga CV-99-387507 Defense Verdict
11. Dapore Arfons Summit CV-1999-10-4269 Settled During Trial
12. Quallich Smith Shaker Heights 01-CVI-00266 Defense Verdict
13. Reinker Robinson Cuyahoga CV-98-370560 Hung Jury
14. Reinker Rogers Cuyahoga CV-99-390671 Defense Verdict
15. Reinker Dinkins Cuyahoga CV-99-393910 Hung Jury
16. Reinker Shafer Cuyahoga CV-00-400053 Plaintiff's Verdict
17. Sweeney Registe Cuyahoga 1:99CV-0583 Defense Verdict
18. Sweeney McCandless Cuyahoga CV-00-413677 Defense Verdict
19. Bonezzi Miller Lorain 98-CV-122310 Plaintiff's Verdict
20. Bonezzi Mahon Cuyahoga 00-CV-421092 Plaintiff's Verdict
21. Bonezzi Busson Medina 99-CIV-1037 Defense Verdict
22. Bonezzi Williams Cuyahoga CV-00-406184 Settled During Trial
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

2000
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Polito Walker Medina 99-CIV-76 Defense Verdict
2. Bonezzi/Hupp Williams Cuyahoga CV-98-356752 Defense Verdict
3. Murphy Ramella Cuyahoga CV-98-369730 Plaintiff's Verdict
4. Hupp Kitchen Lake 98-CV-001626 Defense Verdict
5. Hupp Harmon Cuyahoga CV-99-379799 Defense Verdict
6. Reinker Wright Summit CV-1998-11-4553 Defense Verdict
7. Reinker Brown Cuyahoga CV-99-381834 Plaintiff's Verdict *
8. Sweeney Thomas Cuyahoga CV-00-403519 Plaintiff's Verdict
9. Bonezzi Dalesandro Stark 1998-CVO-1523 Defense Verdict
10. Bonezzi/Hupp Higgins Cuyahoga CV-98-359286 Plaintiff's Verdict
11. Bonezzi Williams Cuyahoga CV-98-356752 Plaintiff's Verdict
12. Bonezzi Woody Cuyahoga CV-99-379784 Plaintiff's Verdict
13. Bonezzi Clemens Cuyahoga CV-98-373204 Settled During Trial
14. Bonezzi Ostergard Summit CV-1996-03-1156 Defense Verdict
15. Bonezzi Dorsey Cuyahoga CV-97-342299 Plaintiff's Verdict
16. Bonezzi Mendicino Cuyahoga CV-98-370606 Plaintiff's Verdict
17. Bonezzi Simons Lorain 98-CV-120542 Defense Verdict
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

1999
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Bonezzi Cunningham Cuyahoga CV-97-322311 Defense Verdict
2. Murphy Cowan-Papesch Cuyahoga CV-98-360027 Defense Verdict
3. Murphy Garcia Cuyahoga CV-97-336292 Plaintiff's Verdict *
4. Reinker McMorrow Cuyahoga CV-96-320150 Defense Verdict
5. Reinker Weatherbee Ashtabula 96-CV-00330 Defense Verdict
6. Reinker Lundmark Cuyahoga CV-98-367359 Defense Verdict
7. Bonezzi Marand Cuyahoga CV-97-323486 Defense Verdict
8. Bonezzi Shropshire Cuyahoga CV-98-354426 Plaintiff's Verdict
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand

| Back to Top |

1998
ATTORNEY CASE NAME COUNTY COUNTY CASE # RESULT
1. Murphy Otero Lorain 97-CV-118004 Defense Verdict
2. Bonezzi Russell Cuyahoga CV-96-312007 Defense Verdict
         

* Verdict was lower than Plaintiff's last settlement demand